• Start a brand new topic
    New Topic
    • Start a brand new topic
  • Search all forums
    Search
    • Search all forums
  • Forum help and frequently asked questions
    Help
    • Forum help and frequently asked questions
STI screen prior to coil fitting
n/a

99 Posts

Posted:  27-Sep-2013 18:32
I have read the posts from June regarding triple swabs and we use the NAATs test for chlamydia and gonorrhoea, we have some GPs semnding patients away with self collection kits while others are requesting endocervical swabs. The thing is, I have contacted the lab and the assistant said that the endocervical swab is more accurate but couldnt give a reason for her answer.
So I would like to know if there is any evidence to say which is better as surely there would be information stating that the self testing swab is not to be used pre coil etc if less reliable??, I noticed Iualua's comments from June so has made me dig further, will see if I can find some info in the meantime.
Smewth
tigha

759 Posts

Posted:  30-Sep-2013 13:55
I think maybe depends where you work. In our area e do naat test for chlamydia and gonnorrhoea which are self swabs
our naat swab for ecs is no different to my knowledge- certainly not we are aware of

But our ecs we do for sensitivities is much less accurate for sensitivities
n/a

99 Posts

Posted:  30-Sep-2013 17:22
Many thanks tigha 
cloe

425 Posts

Posted:  30-Sep-2013 19:22
http://www.bashh.org/documents/3352.pdf
Vaginal specimens have been demonstrated by a number of workers to produce similar sensitivity to cervical testing.14 (IIa, Grade B)
hope this helps answer your query
cloe

n/a

99 Posts

Posted:  30-Sep-2013 21:18
Thanks so much for the article cloe, it's given just what I wanted and there are more links for further reading. I've got so much reading to do!
Smewth
Turtle

0 Posts

Posted:  15-Oct-2013 13:16
I know this is a little late to reply but there is now evidence that blind swabs (done either by a clinician or patient) is more effective than an endocervical swab. Certain STI clinics no longer do endocerical tests on asymptomatic patients. If you think about it the blind swab will be catching more bugs than when using a speculum which opens up the cavity.[8)]
mumnurselover

1425 Posts

Posted:  15-Oct-2013 13:37
turtle do you have the research/guidelines for this please?


n/a

99 Posts

Posted:  16-Oct-2013 06:43
Good point Turtle, thanks, I will try to locate the research.
nakrdnurse

5368 Posts

Posted:  16-Oct-2013 07:38
http://www.fsrh.org/pdfs/CEUGuidanceIntrauterineContraceptionNov07.pdf.


The info is in faculty guidance

Please be informed that the above is personal opinion only.
iPhone App Posted on my iPhone
Please log in to post on the forum. It is free to register.
Some links are only clickable if you are logged in
Featured Jobs
Practice nurse
Lane End Medical Group
We are a large teaching training practice looking to recruit an enthusiastic and motivated Practice Nurse to join our existing nursing team to work 20....
This job offer was posted by laneend2 17 July 2018
Practice Nurse For GP Surgery
Grand Union Health Centre
Grand Union Health Center are looking to recruit a Practice Nurse or Nurse Practitioner to work within our clinical team of 3 Practice Nurses, 2 HCAs,....
This job offer was posted by Grandunionhealthcentre 12 July 2018
Practice Nurse - Corporate Site
nurses.co.uk
Practice Nurse - City Location in large Corporate Investment Bank4 days per week (Mon - Thurs) - 32 hours per week £45k plus excellent benefitsA great....
This job offer was posted by nurses.co.uk 18 July 2018
Fantastic Nurse Opportunity within General Practice
nurses.co.uk
A fantastic opportunity has become available for a specialist respiratory nurse to join a reputable GP surgery in Windsor. The role will be to work ac....
This job offer was posted by nurses.co.uk 11 July 2018
Practice Nurse job, Potters Bar/Barnet
nurses.co.uk
A small, friendly, family-orientated GP Surgery near Barnet/Potters Bar is seeking a Full Time Practice Nurse (or 2x Part-time).This surgery. renowned....
This job offer was posted by nurses.co.uk 11 July 2018
Events
Add Event
Public Personal